LOS ANGELES - The Los Angeles City Council today opted to send its Homelessness and Poverty Committee a motion from Councilman Joe Buscaino to begin the process for a ballot measure that would ban encampments across the city while prioritizing the production of emergency temporary shelter.
The motion was before the full City Council for a vote, but several council members, including Mike Bonin spoke in opposition to it. The council has previously rejected proposals from Buscaino to prohibit camping by people who have been offered shelter.
In an emotional plea to fellow councilmembers, Buscaino said he was tired of sending what should be looked at as a FEMA style emergency to committees for review.
"Let's send this to committee. Let's study the hell out of this while people are dying every day. Where is the compassion and mercy?"
Ultimately, Councilman Paul Krekorian motioned to send the motion to the Homelessness and Poverty Committee, which passed on an 11-2 vote. Buscaino and John Lee -- who had seconded the motion for a ballot measure -- opposed sending it to the committee.
Krekorian said the ballot measure wouldn't solve the underlying challenges the city faces regarding the homelessness crisis The councilman, who also chairs the council's Budget and Finance Committee, added that an ordinance doesn't provide the budget necessary to provide adequate shelter and housing for the city's homeless population.
Buscaino pointed out that every night hundreds of shelter beds go unused in Los Angeles. " I asked that we approved anti-camping rules to ensure the beds don’t go unused. We’ve been engaging people for years."
"We have to triage these souls today. Let’s prioritize emergency housing and not have people waiting on the streets. At the rate we are going streets will forever be a waiting room."
Councilman Mike Bonin said he believes the ballot measure would be solely focused on the problem of the presence of homeless encampments, and not on actually solving the homelessness crisis.
``If we do this measure, if we make enforcement the imperative, if we make enforcement the thing that drives our decisions about what to provide,what type of housing to provide, what type of shelter to provide, it is a guarantee that Los Angeles will provide the lowest common denominator stuff in order to get to enforcement as quickly as possible ... and that's going to be wrong,'' Bonin said.
The chair of the council's Homelessness and Poverty Committee, Councilman Kevin de Leon, who was absent from the meeting, said Friday that he thought a ballot measure would be the wrong approach.
``Since the City Council is actively moving forward policies to address homeless encampments through strategic outreach and housing for people in need, a ballot measure seems the wrong approach. The fact is that a ballot measure would be extremely costly to taxpayers and would likely result in a continuation of the litigation merry-go-round that's kept the city from implementing real solutions,'' he told City News Service.
Had it been approved by the City Council, the motion would have instructed the city attorney to prepare necessary documents to place a measure on the June 2022 primary election ballot that would:
- create a citywide ordinance to prohibit camping in all public areas if shelter is available and offered;
- require the city to prioritize immediate emergency shelter over other options, like permanent supportive housing; and
- provide the mayor with the authority to cut red tape and urgently build emergency homeless housing.
The measure would be on the same ballot as Buscaino, who is running for mayor of Los Angeles.
Under the city's new anti-camping law, which went into effect on Sept. 3, camping in several areas of the city is prohibited, but most of the areas require a City Council vote before enforcement. People camping in areas chosen for enforcement are able to move their tents to other parts of the city if they do not accept shelter options.
In his ballot measure proposal, Buscaino called for a ``FEMA-like emergency response, interim housing and services'' to scale up shelter options so the city can prohibit camping in all areas.
``Why would we continue to allow someone to continue to live on public property if a safer, healthier alternative is available?'' Buscaino asked. ``If there's no appropriate shelter available, there will be no enforcement,'' he added.
According to a pre-pandemic count, 66,436 people were experiencing homelessness in Los Angeles County, with 41,290 of them in the city of Los Angeles.
The city has about 15,000 shelter beds and 24,600 permanent housing slots. Bonin said the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority told him the city only has enough beds for 39% of its homeless population.
Buscaino said in October, when he introduced the motion, that Los Angeles' current system costs too much money and still leaves people on the streets, with about 1,383 homeless people dying in Los Angeles County last year.
"We have a disaster on our streets. Why is our emergency not activated? We are trying to solve this problem form 9-5, but it deserves a 24 hour response."
Los Angeles' 2021-22 fiscal year budget allocates nearly $1 billion to address the crisis. L.A. voters in November 2016 passed Proposition HHH to use $1.2 billion to build 10,000 units for homeless Angelenos, more than tripling Los Angeles' annual production of supportive housing.
On Thursday, ``Safer Streets LA,'' a campaign to pass Buscaino's proposed ballot measure, released a poll from ALG Research that found 64% of 600 likely 2022 primary voters in Los Angeles would support a ballot measure to prohibit encampments in public areas, expand use of temporary housing and allow for expedited development of affordable housing for unhoused residents.
The 64% ranged from ``strongly yes'' to ``lean yes,'' while 28% ranged from ``strongly no'' to ``lean no.'' The remaining 8% were undecided. The poll was conducted from Nov. 9-14.